Neither of my dogs killed a shelter dog General Chat

Kitkat_ · Apr 23, 2014

Just copied and pasted this, saw if a while ago but not sure if you have seen it, the original link isnt working so I have copied the context

“Neither of my dogs killed a shelter dog” – Our favorite Facebook status update in awhile
A big thanks to dog lover (and Facebook friend) Michelle Gonsalves, for this well worded commentary on “purebred dogs creating shelter dogs”. We couldn’t have said it better ourselves. Over the years there’s been a growing number of uninformed voices rallying against the wonderful LOVING world of dog shows and ANY form of dog breeding. We thank Michelle, and any other people brave enough to speak up on the subject!
“Neither of my dogs killed a shelter dog”

A Facebook Status update by Michelle Gonsalves – Reprinted by permission.

I am NOT ashamed to be the owner of two responsibly bred dogs.
Neither of my dogs killed a shelter dog. Neither of my dogs took a shelter dog’s home. Neither of them added to pet overpopulation. If I didn’t have them, I just would not have a dog.

Do you know what kills shelter dogs? Irresponsible owners kill shelter dogs. They kill them when they don’t do their research and add the wrong dog to the wrong household, then ditch it to die at a shelter when they can’t or don’t care to properly care for it.

Let’s not forget that in many breeds, it was responsible breeders who started their breed’s national rescue club. Not to save their own dogs (which don’t need saving), but to save the dogs that they never bred. To save the ones that don’t have safety nets. Responsible breeders did that. They did that in IGs.

I was interviewed more intensely to buy my two responsibly bred dogs than I ever interviewed a rescue candidate. I had supervised visitation… Multiple times. I don’t even own them outright, they are on co-ownership, so that if anything ever happens to me they will go back to their breeder (yes, even the neutered one).

How do I know this will come to pass? I’ve seen her do it with another of her dogs when the owner died unexpectedly. And I saw her do it with my own dog when I nearly died myself. No questions asked, she opened her home to him for as long as I needed her to… Potentially forever, if it came to that. Because that’s what responsible breeders do. And trust me, I researched until I found a responsible breeder.

Added to that, I am PROUD of the responsible breeders in this country who work SO hard to preserve our wonderful breed. Without them, the IG would be an unsound, neurotic, unhealthy creature. Not the elegant, sweet, healthy blessing that I love so much. Without responsible breeders, we’d never have gotten the amazing genetic health tests for enamel hypoplasia, the vonWildebrand’s test, the cda test or the pra test that are on their way.
Without breeders, the domestic dog would CEASE TO BE! I do not ever want to live in a world without dogs. What a terrible place that would be, yet so many professed animal lovers are campaigning through shaming to create just such a world. Because that’s what it means when you say things like “adopt don’t shop,” “don’t breed while shelter dogs die,” and “people who buy dogs from breeders should be ashamed of themselves.”

What do you think will happen if we sterilize all dogs? What do you think will happen if all breeders stop breeding? You’d very quickly loose the rare breeds and the giant breeds FOREVER. Wait a bit more and you’d loose important genetic diversity, causing untold suffering for dogs that have to come from increasingly small gene pools. And then, the dog- man’s best friend- would become extinct. Gone the way of the Dodo. Gone forever. So shame on YOU! Shame on you for hating dogs!

I am not ashamed of my dogs. I am not ashamed of their breeder, who is an amazing person who has given so much of herself for this and other breeds. I am not ashamed of my extended family all around the world in the sport of dogs. And I am not ashamed of myself for daring to want a responsibly bred dog that fits my lifestyle.

Blaming me for the death of shelter dogs is like blaming a parent for the death of orphans in Uganda because she chose to have a baby through pregnancy, rather than adopt one. I have never surrendered an animal in my life. I have never caused the death of a dog in all my life. So why don’t you focus your ire on the people who did– the people who dumped those dogs at the shelter. They are the ones who left those dogs to die. Not me.
Stop bashing your allies. Stop the shaming. We ALL need to work together for the good of dogs. Because there are scary people out there who want your dog gone. Who want you cat gone. Who want the horse out of your paddock, the guide dog out of his harness, the chicken out of the coop and the cow out of the dairy. Keep shilling their slick propaganda and shaming your fellow animal lovers and you help AR militants erase your dog from your very own home.

If anyone has a problem with that, feel free to unfriend me.
Click to expand...

Dogloverlou · Apr 23, 2014

Great article! Thanks for posting

On another forum I was made to feel incredibly guilty for wanting to buy a purebred puppy. I actually got a lot of rude, sarcastic responses and I soon left. While I greatly admire everyone involved in rescue, sometimes the minority can be incredibly pushy and the way they advocate rescue does nothing to help them in the long term, because people like myself would just rather run for the hills!

Trouble · Apr 23, 2014

None of mine did either and although I've had a few rehomes I've never had a rescue dog I just took them on before they ended up in rescue. Horses for courses I don't see what the fuss is about

GsdSlave · Apr 23, 2014

Great article and very true.
if a person decides they want a particular breed of a certain sex/ age they shouldn't be criticised for going to a reputable breeder The problem is based around an oversupply of so called designer dogs,from Puppy Farms & BYB,

It wouldn't matter if everyone stopped buying dogs those who shouldn't be breeding would continue to do so, just as those who shouldn't be owners will still acquire dogs on an impulse and then dump it when they tire of it. There are never any negative consequences to those people, because there is always someone else willing to clean up the mess

Trouble · Apr 23, 2014

They lost my sympathy when they went on about dogs being dumped in rescues to die. Not everyone who gives up a dog to rescue or for rehoming does so without a second thought many can see no alternative. It also implies all dogs in rescue/shelter die which is total nonsense. I agree some dogs won't have a great chance of being rehomed while others will be snapped up.

Jackie · Apr 23, 2014

To be honest I don't give a flying fig for such attitudes, I don't care if something thinks because I buy responsibly bred pure bred dogs, it's killing a poor rescue dog, it's a warped thinking in my book.

I have no issue with those who want to buy from a rescue,, it's up to you to buy from where you want,

Azz · Apr 23, 2014

Have to agree - well bred dogs are not the problem, it's the irresponsible owners, irresponsible breeders and irresponsible 'free-ad' type sites that make back yard breeding and puppy farming so easy

6JRT's · Apr 23, 2014

I have had rescue dogs also brought puppies from a good breeder, it was my own choice & it was what I wanted at that time.

Neither of my dogs killed a shelter dog General Chat

Kitkat_ Member

Neither of my dogs killed a shelter dog

Dogloverlou Member

Trouble Member

GsdSlave Member

Trouble Member

Jackie Member

Azz Adminstrator

6JRT's Member

Share This Page

Official threads